| Rank | Club | Organization Date | Division |
| 1 | Rochester |
1916-05-01 | Genesee |
| 2 | Lockport |
1916-05-17 | Niagara Frontier North |
| 3 | Buffalo |
1916-07-03 | Niagara Frontier South |
| 4 | Albany |
1916-08-10 | Capital |
| 5 | Utica |
1916-09-23 | Central |
| 6 | Troy |
1916-10-25 | Van Rensselaer |
| 7 | Niagara Falls |
1918-12-12 | Niagara Frontier North |
| 8 | Elmira |
1919-05-10 | Chemung |
| 9 | Schenectady |
1919-05-15 | Mohawk |
| 10 | Auburn |
1919-11-13 | Ontario |
| 11 | Watertown Lunch Club |
1920-01-23 | Saint Lawrence |
| 12 | Jamestown |
1920-04-03 | Southwestern |
| 13 | Olean |
1920-05-20 | Southwestern |
| 14 | Tonawandas |
1920-07-02 | Niagara Frontier North |
| 15 | Poughkeepsie |
1920-12-31 | Hudson River |
| 16 | Kingston |
1921-02-10 | Hudson River |
| 17 | Rome |
1921-02-19 | Central |
| 18 | Northern Chautauqua |
1921-03-14 | Southwestern |
| 19 | Newburgh |
1921-05-12 | Hudson River |
| 20 | Oswego |
1921-07-21 | Ontario |
| 21 | Gloversville-Johnstown |
1922-07-28 | Mohawk |
| 22 | Middletown |
1922-10-18 | Hudson River West |
| 23 | Delhi |
1922-11-10 | Susquehanna |
| 24 | Beacon-Fishkill |
1923-02-06 | Hudson River |
| 25 | Batavia |
1923-02-22 | Genesee |
| 26 | Warsaw |
1923-07-17 | Genesee |
| 27 | Oneonta |
1923-11-06 | Susquehanna |
| 28 | Staten Island |
1924-11-06 | Metropolitan |
| 29 | Glens Falls |
1925-03-26 | Mohawk |
| 30 | East Aurora |
1925-07-10 | Niagara Frontier South |
| 31 | Owego |
1925-08-13 | Susquehanna |
| 32 | Broome County |
1925-12-01 | Susquehanna |
| 33 | Baldwinsville |
1925-12-16 | Ontario |
| 34 | Brockport |
1926-06-30 | Genesee |
| 35 | Mount Vernon |
1926-09-24 | Bronx Westchester South |
| 36 | Lake Placid |
1926-11-11 | Adirondack |
| 37 | White Plains |
1926-12-22 | Hudson Tri-County |
| 38 | Kew Forest-Richmond Hill Woodhaven |
1927-03-14 | Queens West |
| 39 | Ticonderoga |
1927-03-31 | Adirondack |
| 40 | Fulton |
1927-09-07 | Ontario |
| 41 | Malone |
1927-11-18 | Saint Lawrence |
| 42 | Frankfort |
1928-03-06 | Central |
| 43 | Hoosick Falls |
1928-05-17 | Van Rensselaer |
| 44 | Rensselaer |
1929-02-14 | Van Rensselaer |
| 45 | Boonville |
1929-03-07 | Central |
| 46 | Plattsburgh Noon |
1929-04-11 | Adirondack |
| 47 | Yonkers |
1929-11-11 | Bronx Westchester South |
| 48 | Ogdensburg |
1931-01-26 | Saint Lawrence |
| 49 | Ithaca-Cayuga |
1932-10-28 | Chemung |
| 50 | Hempstead |
1936-02-20 | Long Island South Central |
| 51 | Gowanda |
1936-10-08 | Southwestern |
| 52 | Freeport |
1936-10-27 | Long Island Southwest |
| 53 | Cortland |
1936-11-12 | Chemung |
| 54 | Seneca Falls-Waterloo |
1937-03-08 | Finger Lakes |
| 55 | Silver Creek |
1937-03-25 | Southwestern |
| 56 | Ken-Ton |
1937-05-13 | Niagara Frontier North |
| 57 | Hicksville |
1937-06-18 | Long Island North |
| 58 | Norwood |
1937-11-30 | Saint Lawrence |
| 59 | Elmsford |
1938-02-03 | Hudson Tri-County |
| 60 | Patchogue |
1938-05-05 | Suffolk East |
| 61 | Elizabethtown |
1938-06-07 | Adirondack |
| 62 | Mamaroneck |
1938-09-09 | Hudson Tri-County |
| 63 | Corning |
1939-01-27 | Chemung |
| 64 | Penn Yan |
1939-02-13 | Finger Lakes |
| 65 | Manhasset-Port Washington |
1939-02-24 | Long Island North |
| 66 | Castleton-On-Hudson |
1939-03-09 | Van Rensselaer |
| 67 | Hornell |
1939-09-08 | Chemung |
| 68 | Salamanca |
1939-10-19 | Southwestern |
| 69 | Dewitt |
1940-04-15 | Ontario |
| 70 | Delmar |
1940-04-22 | Capital |
| 71 | Bayside |
1940-04-29 | Queens East |
| 72 | Amherst |
1940-08-16 | Niagara Frontier North |
| 73 | Roslyn |
1940-10-21 | Long Island North |
| 74 | La Guardia Airport |
1940-12-06 | Queens West |
| 75 | Parkchester, The Bronx |
1941-03-05 | Bronx Westchester South |
| 76 | Greece |
1941-03-13 | Genesee |
| 77 | Brighton |
1942-04-02 | Finger Lakes |
| 78 | Canandaigua |
1943-03-23 | Finger Lakes |
| 79 | Valley Stream |
1943-04-15 | Long Island Southwest |
| 80 | Five Towns (The), Long Island |
1944-03-21 | Long Island Southwest |
| 81 | Baldwin |
1944-10-23 | Long Island Southwest |
| 82 | Oceanside |
1945-09-06 | Long Island Southwest |
| 83 | Roosevelt |
1946-04-24 | Long Island Southwest |
| 84 | Black River |
1946-05-22 | Saint Lawrence |
| 85 | Callicoon |
1946-10-16 | Hudson River West |
| 86 | Monticello |
1946-11-18 | Hudson River West |
| 87 | Chaffee-Sardinia |
1947-01-28 | Niagara Frontier South |
| 88 | Southwest Rochester |
1947-02-06 | Genesee |
| 89 | Roscoe |
1947-04-02 | Hudson River West |
| 90 | Sunnyside |
1947-07-09 | Queens West |
| 91 | Maspeth |
1947-12-08 | Queens West |
| 92 | Solvay-Geddes-Camillus |
1947-12-17 | Ontario |
| 93 | Latham |
1948-07-15 | Capital |
| 94 | Rotterdam |
1948-12-07 | Mohawk |
| 95 | Merrick |
1949-03-31 | Long Island South Central |
| 96 | Massapequa |
1949-06-08 | Long Island South Central |
| 97 | Lakewood |
1949-06-15 | Southwestern |
| 98 | Amityville |
1949-06-16 | Suffolk West |
| 99 | Spring Valley |
1949-08-17 | Hudson Tri-County |
| 100 | Scotia-Glenville |
1949-09-08 | Mohawk |
| 101 | Levittown |
1949-10-27 | Long Island South Central |
| 102 | Sand Lake |
1949-12-05 | Van Rensselaer |
| 103 | Painted Post |
1949-12-14 | Chemung |
| 104 | Ellenburg |
1949-12-20 | Adirondack |
| 105 | Alden |
1949-12-30 | Niagara Frontier South |
| 106 | New Hyde Park |
1950-02-09 | Long Island North |
| 107 | Schoharie |
1950-02-27 | Mohawk |
| 108 | Conklin |
1950-03-01 | Susquehanna |
| 109 | New Scotland |
1950-03-23 | Capital |
| 110 | Lindenhurst |
1950-04-05 | Suffolk West |
| 111 | East Rockaway |
1950-11-08 | Long Island Southwest |
| 112 | Eastwood-East Syracuse |
1950-11-09 | Ontario |
| 113 | Uniondale |
1951-03-27 | Long Island South Central |
| 114 | Elmont |
1951-04-17 | Long Island South Central |
| 115 | Garden City |
1951-07-03 | Long Island South Central |
| 116 | Huntington |
1951-07-26 | Suffolk West |
| 117 | Mount Morris |
1951-11-20 | Genesee |
| 118 | East Meadow |
1952-04-29 | Long Island South Central |
| 119 | Bensonhurst and Bay Ridge, Brooklyn |
1952-06-11 | Brooklyn |
| 120 | Holland |
1952-09-17 | Niagara Frontier South |
| 121 | Saratoga Springs |
1952-10-29 | Mohawk |
| 122 | Riverdale |
1953-05-21 | Bronx Westchester South |
| 123 | Bellmores (The) |
1953-07-21 | Long Island South Central |
| 124 | Glendale |
1953-09-10 | Queens West |
| 125 | Bath |
1953-09-17 | Chemung |
| 126 | Western Turnpike-Guilderland |
1953-11-17 | Capital |
| 127 | Lakeshore-Rochester |
1954-02-15 | Finger Lakes |
| 128 | Clinton |
1954-03-02 | Central |
| 129 | Wantagh |
1954-03-11 | Long Island South Central |
| 130 | Richmond County |
1954-09-20 | Metropolitan |
| 131 | Ozone Park |
1954-11-04 | Queens West |
| 132 | Island Park, Long Island |
1954-11-11 | Long Island Southwest |
| 133 | Owasco-Fleming |
1955-02-16 | Ontario |
| 134 | Ulster |
1955-03-15 | Hudson River |
| 135 | West Hempstead |
1955-06-22 | Long Island South Central |
| 136 | Java-Strykersville |
1955-12-28 | Niagara Frontier South |
| 137 | Gravesend, Brooklyn |
1956-03-08 | Brooklyn |
| 138 | Chenango Valley |
1956-03-12 | Susquehanna |
| 139 | Farmingdale |
1956-06-06 | Long Island North |
| 140 | East Yonkers |
1956-06-14 | Bronx Westchester South |
| 141 | Massena |
1956-11-13 | Saint Lawrence |
| 142 | Hartsdale |
1956-11-15 | Bronx Westchester South |
| 143 | Woodridge |
1956-11-20 | Hudson River West |
| 144 | East Norwich, Oyster Bay |
1956-12-27 | Long Island North |
| 145 | Webster |
1957-05-14 | Finger Lakes |
| 146 | New Hartford |
1957-06-26 | Central |
| 147 | Elma |
1957-07-02 | Niagara Frontier South |
| 148 | Long Beach |
1957-07-23 | Long Island Southwest |
| 149 | Minisink Valley |
1957-10-15 | Hudson River West |
| 150 | Hamburg |
1958-02-06 | Niagara Frontier South |
| 151 | South Shore, Staten Island |
1958-03-10 | Metropolitan |
| 152 | North Syracuse |
1958-03-15 | Ontario |
| 153 | Northport-East Northport |
1958-03-19 | Suffolk West |
| 154 | Lewiston |
1958-03-26 | Niagara Frontier North |
| 155 | Southampton |
1958-06-05 | Suffolk East |
| 156 | Geneseo |
1958-10-27 | Genesee |
| 157 | West Seneca |
1958-11-19 | Niagara Frontier South |
| 158 | Coney Island, Brooklyn |
1958-12-29 | Brooklyn |
| 159 | Lake Delta, Rome |
1959-12-02 | Central |
| 160 | Sayville |
1960-02-17 | Suffolk East |
| 161 | Helderbergs (The), Berne |
1960-03-21 | Capital |
| 162 | Dryden |
1960-05-17 | Chemung |
| 163 | Springville |
1961-04-17 | Niagara Frontier South |
| 164 | Henrietta |
1961-05-09 | Genesee |
| 165 | Nunda |
1961-06-27 | Genesee |
| 166 | Orchard Park |
1961-08-16 | Niagara Frontier South |
| 167 | Howard Beach |
1962-02-01 | Queens West |
| 168 | Penfield-Perinton Townships |
1962-09-13 | Finger Lakes |
| 169 | Port Chester-Rye Brook |
1963-12-11 | Hudson Tri-County |
| 170 | Mastics (The) |
1965-05-19 | Suffolk East |
| 171 | Marilla |
1965-10-05 | Niagara Frontier South |
| 172 | Horseheads |
1966-02-08 | Chemung |
| 173 | Willsboro-Essex |
1966-04-14 | Adirondack |
| 174 | Wales |
1967-06-06 | Niagara Frontier South |
| 175 | York-Leicester |
1967-06-07 | Genesee |
| 176 | Bronx Shore |
1968-07-16 | Bronx Westchester South |
| 177 | Peninsula (The), Hewlett |
1968-10-30 | Long Island Southwest |
| 178 | Byron |
1968-11-21 | Genesee |
| 179 | North Shore, Long Island |
1968-12-31 | Long Island North |
| 180 | Queensbury |
1969-03-25 | Mohawk |
| 181 | Fonda-Fultonville |
1970-03-11 | Mohawk |
| 182 | Westfield |
1970-06-11 | Southwestern |
| 183 | Cambria Heights |
1970-09-29 | Queens East |
| 184 | Wellsville |
1972-09-14 | Southwestern |
| 185 | Eastridge, Irondequoit |
1972-10-01 | Genesee |
| 186 | Pembroke-Corfu-Darien |
1973-03-27 | Genesee |
| 187 | Falconer |
1973-08-14 | Southwestern |
| 188 | New Cassel |
1974-05-14 | Long Island North |
| 189 | Floral Park |
1975-01-21 | Long Island North |
| 190 | Chester |
1975-09-24 | Hudson River West |
| 191 | Golden K Rockaway Blvd South Ozone Park |
1977-02-10 | Queens East |
| 192 | Parkway East, Brooklyn |
1977-10-01 | Brooklyn |
| 193 | County Seat, Mineola |
1977-11-28 | Long Island North |
| 194 | Woodside |
1977-11-28 | Queens West |
| 195 | Rouses Point-Champlain |
1978-04-18 | Adirondack |
| 196 | Brighton, Staten Island |
1978-05-22 | Metropolitan |
| 197 | Rochester West Central |
1978-11-29 | Genesee |
| 198 | Saugerties |
1979-08-28 | Hudson River |
| 199 | West End, Brooklyn |
1980-03-18 | Brooklyn |
| 200 | Gouverneur |
1980-04-22 | Saint Lawrence |
| 201 | Joseph Michael Wuest, Morris Park |
1980-05-01 | Bronx Westchester South |
| 202 | Newark |
1980-06-12 | Finger Lakes |
| 203 | Cohoes |
1980-06-18 | Capital |
| 204 | Eighty Sixth Street, Bath Beach |
1980-08-21 | Brooklyn |
| 205 | Cassadaga Valley |
1980-11-24 | Southwestern |
| 206 | Brooks Senior Center G.K. |
1981-09-18 | Queens East |
| 207 | Spencerport |
1981-09-30 | Genesee |
| 208 | Jefferson Breakfast, Watertown |
1982-02-23 | Saint Lawrence |
| 209 | Town Hall of Hempstead |
1982-12-14 | Long Island South Central |
| 210 | Lefferts-Liberty, Queens County |
1983-01-25 | Queens West |
| 211 | Canton |
1983-12-08 | Saint Lawrence |
| 212 | Glen Lake, Queensbury |
1984-01-12 | Mohawk |
| 213 | Charlotte-Lake Ontario |
1984-02-01 | Finger Lakes |
| 214 | Rockaways (The) |
1984-03-01 | Queens West |
| 215 | Liverpool |
1984-03-15 | Ontario |
| 216 | Chinatown, New York City |
1984-09-06 | Metropolitan |
| 217 | East Hampton |
1985-05-20 | Suffolk East |
| 218 | Catskill |
1985-12-12 | Hudson River |
| 219 | Farmington-Victor |
1986-05-01 | Finger Lakes |
| 220 | Bedford Stuyvesant, Brooklyn |
1986-05-06 | Brooklyn |
| 221 | Copiague |
1986-11-13 | Suffolk West |
| 222 | Astoria-Long Island City |
1987-01-07 | Queens West |
| 223 | Islips, Bay Shore |
1987-01-13 | Suffolk East |
| 224 | Southport |
1987-09-23 | Chemung |
| 225 | Central Adirondacks, Old Forge |
1987-09-30 | Central |
| 226 | Syracuse Brighton Towers |
1988-09-22 | Ontario |
| 227 | North Amityville |
1988-10-01 | Suffolk West |
| 228 | Three Village-Brookhaven Township |
1988-10-18 | Suffolk East |
| 229 | Kings Plaza-Canarsie |
1988-10-19 | Brooklyn |
| 230 | Corona-East Elmhurst |
1989-03-25 | Queens West |
| 231 | Tri-County, Sidney |
1989-07-20 | Susquehanna |
| 232 | Fordham, Bronx |
1989-07-23 | Bronx Westchester South |
| 233 | Potsdam |
1989-08-22 | Saint Lawrence |
| 234 | Livonia |
1990-03-16 | Genesee |
| 235 | Saranac Lake |
1990-08-22 | Adirondack |
| 236 | Jackson Heights, Queens |
1990-09-10 | Queens West |
| 237 | Gates-Greece |
1990-09-18 | Genesee |
| 238 | Greater Westhampton |
1990-09-25 | Suffolk East |
| 239 | Plattsburgh Breakfast |
1990-10-01 | Adirondack |
| 240 | Westchester Village, Bronx |
1990-12-13 | Bronx Westchester South |
| 241 | North Central Staten Island |
1991-03-01 | Metropolitan |
| 242 | Westmoreland |
1991-05-23 | Central |
| 243 | Wilton |
1991-09-24 | Mohawk |
| 244 | Marine Park, Brooklyn |
1991-10-01 | Brooklyn |
| 245 | Nassau County Court Houses |
1992-06-29 | Long Island South Central |
| 246 | Elmwood Avenue, Buffalo |
1992-09-28 | Niagara Frontier South |
| 247 | Greater Riverhead |
1995-02-25 | Suffolk East |
| 248 | Nassau University Medical Center |
1995-07-16 | Long Island South Central |
| 249 | Centereach Seldon |
1995-09-27 | Suffolk East |
| 250 | Queens Boulevard |
1998-09-29 | Queens West |
| 251 | Onondaga Hill |
1999-04-15 | Ontario |
| 252 | Franklin Square |
2000-04-04 | Long Island South Central |
| 253 | Mount Vernon Golden K |
2000-05-09 | Bronx Westchester South |
| 254 | Glen Cove |
2000-06-13 | Long Island North |
| 255 | Putnam County |
2000-06-15 | Hudson Tri-County |
| 256 | Shawangunk Valley, Ellenville |
2000-08-17 | Hudson River West |
| 257 | Mapleton |
2001-09-13 | Brooklyn |
| 258 | Tupper Lake |
2001-09-27 | Adirondack |
| 259 | New York City Young Professionals |
2001-11-19 | Metropolitan |
| 260 | Hollis |
2001-12-05 | Queens East |
| 261 | Palmyra-Macedon |
2001-12-16 | Finger Lakes |
| 262 | Seaford Evening |
2002-06-11 | Long Island South Central |
| 263 | Syracuse Young Professionals |
2002-06-20 | Ontario |
| 264 | Clarence |
2002-08-15 | Niagara Frontier North |
| 265 | St. Albans |
2003-02-11 | Queens East |
| 266 | LeRoy-Pavilion-Stafford |
2004-01-12 | Genesee |
| 267 | Syosset-Woodbury |
2004-02-11 | Long Island North |
| 268 | Rosedale-Laurelton |
2004-05-18 | Queens East |
| 269 | Lakeview |
2004-07-13 | Long Island South Central |
| 270 | North East Bronx |
2004-07-28 | Bronx Westchester South |
| 271 | Port Jervis |
2004-09-14 | Hudson River West |
| 272 | Flushing |
2004-09-24 | Queens East |
| 273 | Cambridge Valley |
2005-10-05 | Van Rensselaer |
| 274 | Jamaica |
2006-05-11 | Queens East |
| 275 | North Greenbush |
2007-07-18 | Van Rensselaer |
| 276 | Plainview, Old Bethpage |
2007-09-27 | Long Island North |
| 277 | Niagara-Wheatfield |
2007-11-15 | Niagara Frontier North |
